Trading Strategy Based on Bollinger Bands and MACD
Author: ChaoZhang, Date: 2023-12-20 15:55:18Tags:
Overview
This strategy combines Bollinger Bands and MACD indicator to identify oversold opportunities and trend reversals for quantitative trading. The strategy name is “Bollinger MACD Reversal Strategy”.
Strategy Logic
The strategy first calculates 20-day Bollinger Bands, including middle band, upper band and lower band. When price touches the lower band, it considers the market oversold. At this point, combine with MACD indicator to judge whether the trend is reversing. If MACD histogram crosses above signal line positively, it determines the end of this round of decline, which corresponds to the buy signal.
Specifically, touching the Bollinger lower band and MACD histogram crossing signal line positively triggers the buy signal simultaneously. When close price rises above the stop loss level, it triggers the take profit signal.
Advantage Analysis
The strategy integrates Bollinger Bands to judge oversold zone and MACD to determine trend reversal signals, realizing relatively lower entry price. It also includes take profit methods to lock in profits and avoid losses.
In particular, the advantages are:
- Combining Bollinger Bands oversold zone and MACD indicator to achieve better entry points
- Using MACD indicator to determine trend reversal points, reducing false breakout probabilities
- Adopting stop loss/take profit methods to effectively control risks
Risk Analysis
There are still some risks mainly in the following aspects:
- Probability of Bollinger Bands breakout exists, which may cause failure in oversold zone judgement
- MACD histogram crossover could also be false one with judgement error probability
- Stop loss position setting may be improper, either too loose or strict, leading to insufficient defence or premature stop loss
To hedge against the above risks, we can take the following measures:
- Combine with other indicators to verify validity of Bollinger Bands breakout signals
- Add momentum indicators etc. as filters to avoid MACD false crossover
- Optimize and test different stop loss parameters
Optimization Directions
There is still room for further optimization, mainly including:
- Optimize Bollinger Bands parameters to find better oversold judgement schemes
- Add momentum indicators filters to improve MACD judgement validity
- Test stop loss methods like ATR to find better parameters
- Add trend judgement module to avoid counter trend trading
- Combine machine learning methods to train judgement models and improve overall strategy performance
Conclusion
The strategy integrates Bollinger Bands oversold zone judgement and MACD trend reversal indicator to achieve relatively better entry points. It also sets up stop loss/take profit methods to control risks. This is a worthwhile low buy high sell strategy to reference and optimize. Combined with more indicator filters and machine learning methods, there is still space to further improve its performance.
/*backtest
start: 2023-11-19 00:00:00
end: 2023-12-19 00:00:00
period: 1h
basePeriod: 15m
exchanges: [{"eid":"Futures_Binance","currency":"BTC_USDT"}]
*/
// This source code is subject to the terms of the Mozilla Public License 2.0 at https://mozilla.org/MPL/2.0/
// © DojiEmoji
//@version=4
strategy("[KL] BOLL + MACD Strategy v2 (published)",overlay=true)
// BOLL bands {
BOLL_length = 20
BOLL_src = close
BOLL_mult = 2.0
BOLL_basis = sma(BOLL_src, BOLL_length)
BOLL_dev = BOLL_mult * stdev(BOLL_src, BOLL_length)
BOLL_upper = BOLL_basis + BOLL_dev
BOLL_lower = BOLL_basis - BOLL_dev
BOLL_offset = 0
plot(BOLL_basis, "Basis", color=#872323, offset = BOLL_offset)
BOLL_p1 = plot(BOLL_upper, "Upper", color=color.navy, offset = BOLL_offset, transp=50)
BOLL_p2 = plot(BOLL_lower, "Lower", color=color.navy, offset = BOLL_offset, transp=50)
fill(BOLL_p1, BOLL_p2, title = "Background", color=#198787, transp=85)
// }
// MACD signals {
MACD_fastLen = 12
MACD_slowLen = 26
MACD_Len = 9
MACD = ema(close, MACD_fastLen) - ema(close, MACD_slowLen)
aMACD = ema(MACD, MACD_Len)
MACD_delta = MACD - aMACD
// }
backtest_timeframe_start = input(defval = timestamp("01 Nov 2010 13:30 +0000"), title = "Backtest Start Time", type = input.time)
//backtest_timeframe_end = input(defval = timestamp("05 Mar 2021 19:30 +0000"), title = "Backtest End Time", type = input.time)
TARGET_PROFIT_MODE = input(false,title="Exit when Risk:Reward met")
REWARD_RATIO = input(3,title="Risk:[Reward] (i.e. 3) for exit")
// Trailing stop loss {
var entry_price = float(0)
ATR_multi_len = 26
ATR_multi = input(2, "ATR multiplier for stop loss")
ATR_buffer = atr(ATR_multi_len) * ATR_multi
risk_reward_buffer = (atr(ATR_multi_len) * ATR_multi) * REWARD_RATIO
take_profit_long = low > entry_price + risk_reward_buffer
take_profit_short = low < entry_price - risk_reward_buffer
var bar_count = 0 //number of bars since entry
var trailing_SL_buffer = float(0)
var stop_loss_price = float(0)
stop_loss_price := max(stop_loss_price, close - trailing_SL_buffer)
// plot TSL line
trail_profit_line_color = color.green
if strategy.position_size == 0
trail_profit_line_color := color.blue
stop_loss_price := low
plot(stop_loss_price,color=trail_profit_line_color)
// }
var touched_lower_bb = false
if true// and time <= backtest_timeframe_end
if low <= BOLL_lower
touched_lower_bb := true
else if strategy.position_size > 0
touched_lower_bb := false//reset state
expected_rebound = MACD > MACD[1] and abs(MACD - aMACD) < abs(MACD[1] - aMACD[1])
buy_condition = touched_lower_bb and MACD > aMACD or expected_rebound
//ENTRY:
if strategy.position_size == 0 and buy_condition
entry_price := close
trailing_SL_buffer := ATR_buffer
stop_loss_price := close - ATR_buffer
strategy.entry("Long",strategy.long, comment="buy")
bar_count := 0
else if strategy.position_size > 0
bar_count := bar_count + 1
//EXIT:
// Case (A) hits trailing stop
if strategy.position_size > 0 and close <= stop_loss_price
if close > entry_price
strategy.close("Long", comment="take profit [trailing]")
stop_loss_price := 0
else if close <= entry_price and bar_count
strategy.close("Long", comment="stop loss")
stop_loss_price := 0
bar_count := 0
// Case (B) take targeted profit relative to risk
if strategy.position_size > 0 and TARGET_PROFIT_MODE
if take_profit_long
strategy.close("Long", comment="take profits [risk:reward]")
stop_loss_price := 0
bar_count := 0
- SMA RSI & Sudden Buy Sell Strategy
- Dual-factor Quantitative Reversal Tracking Strategy
- Ehlers Instantaneous Trendline Strategy
- Dual EMA Golden Cross Breakthrough Strategy
- Bull and Bear Power Moving Average Trading Strategy
- Quantitative Strategy: Bollinger Bands RSI CCI Crossover Strategy
- The VWAP breakout tracking strategy
- Momentum Reversal Trading Strategy
- Momentum Tracking Trading Strategy
- Multiple Weighted Moving Averages Trend Strategy
- Macd Blue Red Leverage Strategy
- Momentum Capture Channel Strategy
- Hedging Oscillation Reversal Strategy
- Quantitative Trading Strategy Based on Bollinger Bands and RSI
- The Relative Volume Indicator Strategy
- The Octagon Cloud Tracing Strategy
- Probability-Enhanced RSI Strategy
- Triple EMA Trend Following Strategy
- Stan The Man - An Advanced Stock Trading Strategy Based on Dual Moving Average and Volatility
- Reverse Mean Breakthrough Strategy